This research is made possible by our readers. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research
HOMEaaBest Pillows 2019aaMyPillow Classic Pillow Review

MyPillow Classic Pillow Review

Andy David
Review by Andy David
Pillow expert Updated Oct 2019

Our Review Process

Our team researched and analyzed over 11,164 verified MyPillow Classic pillow customer reviews. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research.

Quick Overview

MyPillow Classic is a popular pillow made from cotton and shredded polyfoam. It is lightweight, easily adjustable, and washable.

But the pillow has mixed reviews. Many people think the price is high for average quality. Others say the pillow causes neck pain.

  • Good – Has a patented interlocking fill to help the pillow keep its shape.
  • Bad – High price for the quality of materials. Some customers report neck pain.
  • Buy or not – Buy for a lightweight, easy to wash pillow with many fill options. Shoppers on a budget or want a luxurious feel should look elsewhere.

Pros

  • Available in 4 different fill levels
  • Easy washing and drying
  • Designed and made in the USA
  • Can help to reduce snoring
  • Fast and affordable shipping

Cons

  • “Lumpy” texture does not suit everyone
  • Can sleep hot on warm nights
  • Some reports the pillow loses shape
  • Slight odor after unpacking
  • Cheap materials for the price

MyPillow Classic Pillow customer ratings

Category

Rating

Customer Experience Summary

Comfort

 Good

There are many reports of good comfort. But some customers say the pillow causes neck pain

Quality

 Good

Customers think the quality is good. But nothing special. It feels like a basic pillow

Value

 Not good

Many people say the pillow is expensive for the quality. Customers can get cheaper pillows in major stores

Cooling

 Good

Most customers think the pillow sleeps cool. But people who sleep hot need better cooling

Side Sleepers

 Good

The higher fill options work well for side sleepers. The pillow keeps its shape (to minimize neck pain)

Neck & Back Pain

 Good

Customers report good back and neck pain relief. But other people say the pillow made their pain worse

Firmness & Height Options

 Good

People like the choice of 4 firmness/height options. This gives plenty of flexibility

Smell/Off-gassing

 Good

There are few reports of any odor. There is a slight smell. But this soon goes away

Cleaning

 Excellent

Most customers say cleaning and drying are easy. But drying can take longer than expected

Returns & Warranty

 Excellent

The 60-day money back guarantee is popular. But customers do not like paying return shipping fees

Lifespan

 Good

Customers think the pillow retains its shape well. The lifespan is above average

Company Reputation

 Good

MyPillow is popular and has a decent reputation. But there are many complaints as well

Everything you need to know about MyPillow Classic Pillow

4 Loft Options Available For All Body Weights

MyPillow Classic comes in 4 different loft (height) levels. There is a good choice for different body weights and sleeping styles.

The options range from Least Firm to Most Firm. Each option has a color code: Yellow, White, Green, and Blue.

Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
 Good

Heavy sleepers enjoy the lower fill options best. This prevents neck pain if the mattress has a level of sinkage

Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
 Good

Most average weight sleepers are fine with the medium fill option. It provides good all-around neck support

Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
 Good

Lightweight sleepers get good neck and shoulder support. But some people need a firmer fill level (Green model)

Cotton & Shredded Polyfoam Keeps The Pillow Supportive

MyPillow Classic is made from a 100% cotton cover and shredded polyfoam. The patented interlocking fill adapts to every sleeping position.

  • Cotton Cover – A 100% ring-spun cotton cover. Provides good breathability and makes the pillow easy to wash and dry.
  • Shredded Polyfoam – Inside the pillow, there are shredded pieces of polyfoam. These hold position and ensure the pillow never goes flat.

Options Available For Different Sleeping Positions

It is important to consider sleeping positions when buying a pillow. Different loft heights work best for certain positions.

Side sleepers
Side sleepers
Side sleepers
 Good

Side sleepers like how they can fluff the pillow. Keeping it in shape means less neck pain

Back sleepers
Back sleepers
Back sleepers
 Good

Back sleepers say they snore less and get a better night’s sleep. But some people do not like the shredded foam texture

Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
 Good

Lower fill options work well for stomach sleepers. But some heavy stomach sleepers need a flatter pillow

Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
 Good

Sleepers enjoy customizing the pillow to each position. It keeps its shape allowing people to get the perfect comfort

Trial Period And Full Warranty Details

Sleep trial

60-Day

Refund

60-day money back guarantee

Warranty

10-Year

Customers get a 10-year warranty as standard. This warranties the pillow not to go flat.

The pillow keeps its shape well. But most customers need to re-plump it from time to time. The expected lifespan is between 2 and 3 years.

Risk-Free Trial Details

  • 60-day money back guarantee
  • Customers must cover return shipping costs
  • Full refund within 30 days of return

Warranty Details

  • 10-year manufacturer warranty
  • Valid no matter how much washing or drying
  • Company will replace a defective pillow

MyPillow Classic Positive Customer Reviews

There are many positive reviews of MyPillow Classic. But the reviews are mixed.

  • Easy Washing & Drying – Customers say washing and drying the pillow is easy. But tumble drying time can take longer than expected.
  • Molds To Position – Most people like how the pillow molds into position. Many customers like the shredded polyfoam fill.
  • Neck Pain Relief – There are positive reports of neck pain relief. Customers like how they can customize the support.

MyPillow Classic Customer Complaints

There are many complaints about MyPillow Classic. But most complaints focus on poor value.

  • Overpriced – Many buyers do not feel the pillow is a good value. People think it is expensive for the level of quality.
  • Regular Replumping – The pillow needs regular replumping. 15 minutes on high heat in the dryer works best.
  • Lumpy Feel – Some people do not like the “lumpy” feel. But there are many customers who find the pillow comfortable.

Shipping

Shipping Method

Ships by local mail office or courier

Pillow Care

Wash on a non-delicate setting using a regular cycle. Place the pillow in a tumble dryer for 15 minutes

  • Standard shipping within 7 to 10 business days ($9.98)
  • FedEx courier shipping within 2 to 5 business days ($19.95)
  • Fast mail office delivery within 2 to 5 business days ($19.95)
  • Returns need customers to cover shipping costs

  • Wash cold or warm on a regular cycle
  • Wash pillow with a load of laundry
  • Tumble dry on high heat (15 minutes or more)

MyPillow Classic Pillow Prices

MyPillow Classic is available from $59.99. This is above average for a pillow of this standard.

Some customers think the pillow is a good value. But many shoppers think it is overpriced.

Swipe left to view more

Size

Dimensions

Price

Standard/Queen

18.5W″x28L″

King

18.5W″x34L″

Where Is The MyPillow Classic Pillow Made?

MyPillow Classic is designed and made in the USA. Michael Lindell developed the pillow because he had trouble sleeping.

The company also sells pillow cases, bed sheets, and mattresses. The full range of items is available on the MyPillow website.

Easy & Fast Setup - But Needs Drying Before Use

The company recommends placing the pillow in the dryer for 15 minutes before use. This gives the pillow its natural plumpness.

Some customers report a slight smell after unboxing. The odor is hardly noticeable.

Should You Buy A MyPillow Classic Pillow?

Shoppers looking for a pillow that adapts to any position should consider MyPillow Classic. It is easy to wash and dry, has a 60-day trial period, and a 10-year warranty.

But many people think the price is too high. Buyers on a budget or who prefer natural materials should try other brands.

Consider Before Buying:

  • “Lumpy” Texture – There is a shredded polyfoam fill. This creates a lumpy feel that some people dislike.
  • Above Average Price – The price is high for the level of quality. Many people think MyPillow Classic is expensive.
  • 4 Loft Levels – Customers can choose from 4 loft (height) levels. It is important to get the right level. Otherwise, neck and shoulder pain can occur.

Frequently Asked Questions

MyPillow Classic comes in Queen size (18.5-inch x 28-inch) and King size (18.5-inch x 34-inch).

Most customers find the pillow good for side sleeping. But customers must select the right fill level to prevent neck pain.

The pillow is breathable and sleeps cool. But a few people find the higher fill options sleep hot.

MyPillow Classic comes in 4 fill levels. These range from Yellow (Least Firm) to Blue (Most Firm).

The pillow is available in 4 loft heights. These include Least Firm, Medium Fill, More Fill, and Most Firm.

Customers say that MyPillow Classic helps with neck pain. But it is important to choose the right fill level.

MyPillow Classic is made from a 100% cotton cover and a shredded polyfoam fill.

MyPillow Classic is made from polyfoam. This material contains chemicals that could potentially be toxic.

The pillow is designed and made in the USA.

MyPillow Classic has a 10-year warranty. But most pillows last around 2 to 3 years.

Customers report a minor odor. But this soon goes away.

There is a 60-day money back guarantee. Customers can return the pillow for a refund. But people must pay return shipping charges.

MyPillow Classic Pillow review summary

Overall rating

3.9 out of 5
3.9 out of 5
Andy David
Rated & Review by Andy David
Comfort
 Good
Quality
 Good
Value
 Not good
Side Sleepers
 Good
Neck & Back Pain
 Good
Cooling
 Good
Smell/Off-gassing
 Good
Company Reputation
 Good

Good

Has a patented interlocking fill to help the pillow keep its shape.

Bad

High price for the quality of materials. Some customers report neck pain.

Buy or not

Buy for a lightweight, easy to wash pillow with many fill options. Shoppers on a budget or want a luxurious feel should look elsewhere.

Where To Buy The MyPillow Classic Pillow?

The best place to buy the MyPillow Classic pillow is on the official website.

About the author

Andy David
Andy David Mattress expert

Andy is the chief editor at Sleep Cupid. Andy researches and reviews leading mattress brands to help our readers get the right mattress and enjoy better rest.