This research is made possible by our readers. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research
HOMEaaBest Pillows 2019aaMyPillow Premium Pillow Review

MyPillow Premium Pillow Review

Andy David
Review by Andy David
Pillow expert Updated Oct 2019

Our Review Process

Our team researched and analyzed over 7,452 verified My Pillow Premium pillow customer reviews. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research.

Quick Overview

My Pillow Premium is a washable pillow made from cotton and shredded polyfoam. The patented design molds into shape for great neck support.

But the pillow is expensive. Some customers do not like the “lumpy” texture. Others report a crunching sound when moving positions.

  • Good – Lightweight pillow that stays in shape. Easy to wash and tumble dry.
  • Bad – Expensive compared to budget pillows. Needs regular replumping in dryer.
  • Buy or not – Buy for an easy to wash pillow that molds into position. Shoppers on a budget or who prefer flatter pillows should try other brands.

Pros

  • Patented interlocking fill design
  • Keeps shape in all sleeping positions
  • 60-day money back guarantee
  • Easy to wash and tumble dry
  • Choice of 4 fill (firmness) levels

Cons

  • Drying takes longer than expected
  • “Lumpy” texture does not suit everyone
  • Overstuffed and too firm for some people
  • Needs regular replumping in dryer
  • Expensive for the quality of materials

My Pillow Premium Pillow customer ratings

Category

Rating

Customer Experience Summary

Comfort

 Good

Most people say the pillow is comfortable. But choosing the right fill level is key to avoiding neck pain

Quality

 Good

Customers think the pillow is durable enough for regular use. But some people say the materials are basic and cheap

Value

 Not good

Shoppers think the pillow is overpriced. But people who get good comfort think it is a great value

Cooling

 Good

Most people have no problem with overheating. But some people find the pillow gets too hot

Side Sleepers

 Excellent

Most side sleepers like My Pillow Premium. People get good neck support with the higher fill levels

Neck & Back Pain

 Good

Many customers say they no longer get neck pain. But some people say their neck pain got worse

Firmness & Height Options

 Excellent

Customers like having 4 firmness options to choose from. This works for different body weights and sleeping styles

Smell/Off-gassing

 Good

Most people report no major odor. There is a slight smell but this soon goes away

Cleaning

 Excellent

Many customers find washing and cleaning easy. This works well for sleepers with allergies

Returns & Warranty

 Excellent

Customers have confidence in the 10-year warranty. They also like the 60- day money back guarantee

Lifespan

 Good

Reports about the lifespan are good. Most people get at least 3 years of comfortable use

Company Reputation

 Good

My Pillow has a good reputation. But the company has mixed reviews about its pillows

Everything you need to know about My Pillow Premium Pillow

4 Loft Options For Different Body Weights

Customers can choose from 4 loft (height) options. Each version has a color code: Yellow, White, Green, and Blue.

My Pillow Premium has more fill capacity than My Pillow Classic. For sleepers who want a more supportive pillow, the brand is a good choice.

Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
 Good

Heavy people usually need thinner pillows. Most heavy customers get good comfort on Yellow (Least Firm)

Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
 Excellent

Average weight sleepers report good neck support on White (Medium Fill). But this depends on sleeping position

Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
 Good

Lightweight sleepers like the extra fill My Pillow Premium has. Back and side sleepers report great neck support

Simple But Effective Design - Cotton & Polyfoam Construction

The pillow is made from cotton and shredded polyurethane foam. The patented interlocking fill lets customers shape the pillow however they want.

  • Cotton Cover – A soft and breathable cotton cover. There is a gusset stitched into the side to make the pillow thicker.
  • Shredded Polyfoam – The fill contains shredded polyurethane foam. This material locks into shape when customers plump the pillow.

Works For Most Sleeping Positions - But There Is Above Average Fill

Most customers find My Pillow Premium comfortable. But there is more loft than people realize.

Side sleepers
Side sleepers
Side sleepers
 Excellent

Side sleepers say the pillow can be molded to the perfect shape. They get good neck support in this position

Back sleepers
Back sleepers
Back sleepers
 Good

Back sleepers report less snoring and improved neck support. But the right fill level is key to overall comfort

Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
 Good

Stomach sleepers like the low fill options best. But some heavy stomach sleepers say the pillow has too much fill

Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
 Good

White (Medium Fill) provides all-around comfort and support. But the crunching  noise can be annoying for some

Trial Period And Full Warranty Details

Sleep trial

60-Day

Refund

60-day money back guarantee

Warranty

10-Year

My Pillow Premium has a 10-year warranty. The company will replace a defective pillow.

Customers can expect My Pillow Premium to last 2 to 3 years. Most customers say the pillow keeps its shape well. But regular replumping is needed.

Risk-Free Trial Details

  • 60-day money back guarantee
  • Customers must cover return shipping costs
  • Full refund within 30 days of return

Warranty Details

  • 10-year manufacturer warranty
  • Valid no matter how much washing or drying
  • Covers manufacturing and material defects only

My Pillow Premium Pillow Positive Customer Reviews

There are many positive reviews about My Pillow Premium. Most sleepers comment on the good neck support.

  • Less Neck Pain – Many customers report neck pain relief. People get a better night’s sleep and awake feeling refreshed.
  • Easy Wash & Dry – Customers say washing and drying is easy. But some people say tumble drying takes longer than expected.
  • Holds Its Position – Many customers say the pillow keeps its shape after plumping. Sleepers can mold the pillow to suit their favorite sleeping position.

My Pillow Premium Pillow Customer Complaints

Although many people like My Pillow Premium, there are complaints. Some people think the pillow is overpriced for the level of quality.

  • Needs Replumping – Many customers say the pillow goes flat without constant replumping. It is inconvenient to keep placing the pillow in the dryer. 
  • Texture & Sound – Some customers do not like the “lumpy” texture. Others say the mattress is loud and makes a crunching sound.
  • Above Average Price – Some people find the price too expensive. Customers wonder if the materials are really worth the cost.

Shipping

Shipping Method

Ships by FedEx or local mail office

Pillow Care

Wash and dry every 4 months, even if clean. Wash on a regular cycle. Dry in tumble dryer

  • Standard shipping within 7 to 10 business days ($9.98)
  • FedEx shipping within 2 to 5 business days ($19.95)
  • Fast mail office delivery within 2 to 5 business days ($19.95)
  • For returns, customers must cover transportation costs

  • Wash every 4 months. Or every 2 months if prone to allergies
  • Use warm or cold water on a regular cycle (not delicate)
  • Tumble dry on high heat. Do not worry about over-drying

My Pillow Premium Pillow Prices

The pillow is $69.98 for a Standard/Queen size. And $79.98 for a King size.

Many people think the price is too high. But customers who like the pillow say the comfort is worth the expense.

Swipe left to view more

Size

Dimensions

Price

Standard/Queen

16.5W″x26L″

King

16.5W″x32L″

Where Is The My Pillow Premium Pillow Made?

My Pillow Premium is made in the USA. It is an upgraded version of My Pillow Classic.

The pillow forms part of Michael Lindell’s range of bedding products. This includes pillow cases, mattresses, bed sheets, and more.

Use My Pillow Premium In Minutes - But Tumble Dry Before Use

Customers can use My Pillow Premium in minutes. But they should tumble dry it for 15 minutes before use.

This will return its plumpness. There is a slight odor at first. But this soon goes away.

Should You Buy A My Pillow Premium Pillow?

Shoppers who want a pillow that molds into position should consider My Pillow Premium. It has 4 loft (height) options and is easy to wash and dry.

But the shredded polyfoam feel is not for everyone. Buyers on a budget can get better value elsewhere.

Consider Before Buying:

  • Choice Of 4 Loft Levels – There are 4 loft (height) levels available. This allows customers to choose the perfect firmness and feel.
  • Lumpy Texture/Crunchy Sound – Shredded polyfoam has a “lumpy” texture that molds into position. Customers report a crunching sound when tossing and turning.
  • High Price For Cheap Materials – Many people think the pillow is overpriced. For cheap materials, the price is above average.

Frequently Asked Questions

My Pillow Premium is available in Standard/Queen size (16.5-inch x 26-inch + 2-inch), and King size (16.5-inch x 32-inch + 2-inch).

The pillow is good for most side sleepers. But choosing the right loft level is key. Otherwise neck and back pain can occur.

Most people who comment on heat say the pillow sleeps cool. But some customers find they overheat at night.

My Pillow Premium is available in 4 firmness options. Each is color-coded from Yellow (Least Firm) to Blue (Most Firm).

Customers can choose from 4 loft options. These include Yellow (Least Firm), White (Medium Fill), Green (More Fill), and Blue (Most Firm).

There are many reports of neck pain relief. But choosing the right fill level is key.

The pillow has a shredded polyfoam fill. It also has a ring-spun cotton cover.

My Pillow Premium has a shredded polyfoam fill. Polyurethane can contain small amounts of toxic substances.

The pillow is designed by Michael Lindell and made in the USA.

Most customers can expect the pillow to last around 2 to 3 years. This is typical of most pillows of this standard.

There is a slight smell at first. But any odor will soon disappear.

Customers benefit from a 60-day money back guarantee. The company will provide a full refund (minus return shipping costs).

My Pillow Premium Pillow review summary

Overall rating

4.1 out of 5
4.1 out of 5
Andy David
Rated & Review by Andy David
Comfort
 Good
Quality
 Good
Value
 Not good
Side Sleepers
 Excellent
Neck & Back Pain
 Good
Cooling
 Good
Smell/Off-gassing
 Good
Company Reputation
 Good

Good

Lightweight pillow that stays in shape. Easy to wash and tumble dry.

Bad

Expensive compared to budget pillows. Needs regular replumping in dryer.

Buy or not

Buy for an easy to wash pillow that molds into position. Shoppers on a budget or who prefer flatter pillows should try other brands.

Where To Buy The My Pillow Premium Pillow?

The best place to buy the My Pillow Premium pillow is on the official website.

About the author

Andy David
Andy David Mattress expert

Andy is the chief editor at Sleep Cupid. Andy researches and reviews leading mattress brands to help our readers get the right mattress and enjoy better rest.