HOMEaaBest Mattress 2019aaBest Innerspring Mattress 2019

Helping mattress shoppers get the right mattress since 2016

Best Innerspring Mattress 2019

See the expert's choice for best value, side sleepers and back pain
Andy David
Guide by Andy DavidUpdated September 2019

Our Review Process & Trust Policy

Our team researched and analyzed over 150,000 verified mattress customer reviews. We tested and sleep trialed mattresses to help with research. We’re committed to honesty and trust – showing you the truth about mattresses. This research is made possible by our readers. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research.

Quick Summary - Best Innerspring Mattress Ratings

To help you find the best innerspring mattress, we read over 150,000 genuine mattress customer reviews. Our top recommendations are based on verified customer reviews and our mattress testing.

If you need more information and details, below are reviews for each mattress.

Best Innerspring Mattress Reviews

DreamCloud is a luxury hybrid mattress made from pocket coils, memory foam, and latex. The mattress has medium firmness that most sleepers will enjoy.
  • Great Comfort – Comfortable for different body weights and sleeping positions. Pocket coils provide great support to reduce back pain.
  • Good Value – DreamCloud is a luxury mattress in a box. It is more affordable than in-store brands of similar standard.
  • Durable Materials – The mattress has a durable construction that can withstand regular use. Even heavy people find DreamCloud strong and supportive.

Pros

  • Excellent comfort and support
  • Great value for the money bed
  • Strong, supportive mattress

Cons

  • Only one firmness option (medium)
  • Tall, heavy mattress that is difficult to lift
  • Unsuitable for buyers on a budget
Brooklyn Aurora is a hybrid mattress available in 3 firmness options (soft, medium, firm). The mattress works well for side sleepers who need good pressure relief.
  • Pressure Relief – Side sleepers say the mattress protects the shoulders and hips. This relieves aches and pains for improved sleep quality.
  • Cooling Technology – The mattress is one of the coolest on the market. Gel-infused foam and pocket coils keep side sleepers cool.
  • Made In USA – Brooklyn Aurora is made in the USA from high-quality materials. The company owns its own factory and this shows in the mattress quality.

Pros

  • Good choice for side sleepers
  • Advanced cooling technology
  • Works for different body weights

Cons

  • Returns can be difficult at times
  • Heavy mattress that is tricky to lift
  • Taller height than most mattress brands
Alexander Hybrid is a great value, quality hybrid bed made in the USA. The mattress has many positive reviews from customers.
  • All-Around Support – Pocket coils stop sagging and keep the body afloat. Foam layers deliver pressure relief to minimize aches and pains.
  • Great Value – Alexander Hybrid is a great value for the quality of materials. Customers say the mattress has a premium feel at an affordable price.
  • Good For Couples – Split firmness options are available for couples. The mattress also has good edge support and motion isolation.

Pros

  • Great value, luxury hybrid mattress
  • Good comfort for all sleeping positions
  • Good airflow and temperature regulation

Cons

  • Reasonable price, but not cheap
  • Heavy mattress that is difficult to move
  • Odor after unboxing (but goes away)
brooklyn-bedding-signature-mattress
Brooklyn Signature is a hybrid mattress made from pocket coils and quality foams. 3 firmness options provide great back support for different body weights.
  • Back Pain Relief – The firmer options provide excellent lumbar support. Many customers say their back pain went away after using the bed.
  • Great Support – Pocket coils keep the body afloat in different positions. Heavy people and stomach sleepers also get good back pain relief.
  • Good Bounce – Couples say the mattress has the bounce of an innerspring mattress. Customers get the perfect balance between foam and coils.

Pros

  • Reliable support for all body weights
  • Many reports of back pain relief
  • Made in the USA from quality materials

Cons

  • Edge support is average for heavy people
  • Squeaking sound when under intense pressure
  • 30-night minimum trial period before returns
saatva-mattress
Saatva is a luxury hybrid mattress made from innersprings, pocket coils, and memory foam. It has a classic innerspring feel with the added comfort of foam.
  • Many Options – The mattress is available in 3 firmness choices and 2 thickness options. But all firmness options are firmer than expected.
  • Great Value – Saatva has a competitive price that is cheaper than most hybrids. With a queen size just over $1000, Saatva is a great value.
  • No Off-Gassing – Customers get free white glove delivery. The mattress arrives whole (not compressed in a box). This means there is no off-gassing odor.

Pros

  • Available in 3 firmness options
  • Free white glove delivery
  • Solid support and great bounce

Cons

  • Untested durability (new mattress brand)
  • No soft option for lightweight sleepers
  • $99 transportation fee for mattress returns
eco-terra-mattress
Eco Terra is a hybrid mattress made from natural latex and pocket coils. It sleeps cool and provides great support for all sleeping positions.
  • Natural Latex – Latex is responsive and great for allergy sufferers. The material is temperature neutral and sleeps cooler than memory foam.
  • Two Firmness Options – The mattress is available in medium and medium-firm options. This provides comfort and support for most body weights.
  • Excellent Cooling – The hybrid design of pocket coils and latex provide great airflow. Customers say the mattress sleeps cool, even on warm nights.

Pros

  • Eco-friendly and hypoallergenic
  • Great support and bounce
  • Competitively priced for natural latex

Cons

  • No soft or firm option available
  • Average motion isolation for couples
  • New company with untested durability
brooklyn-bedding-signature-mattress
Brooklyn Signature is a quality hybrid mattress made from pocket coils and cooling foams. It has 3 firmness options and works for back, side, and stomach sleepers.
  • Bounce & Response – The mattress is made from pocket coils that give the bounce of an innerspring bed. Customers enjoy the responsive and supportive feel.
  • Great Support – Brooklyn Signature keeps sleepers afloat on the mattress. Customers report good pressure relief and reliable back support.
  • Affordable Price – Since it is made in a dedicated factory, the mattress is a great value. High-quality, USA-made materials give good durability.

Pros

  • Strong pocket coils for great support
  • A bouncy and responsive mattress
  • Good edge support for couples

Cons

  • 30-night minimum trial period before returns
  • No split firmness options for couples
  • Delivery delays can happen during busy periods
plushbeds-luxury-bliss-mattress
PlushBeds Luxury Bliss is a hybrid mattress made from 100% organic latex and pocket coils. It is a competitively priced, eco-friendly option.
  • 100% Organic Latex – Luxury Bliss is made from certified organic latex. The mattress has no harmful chemicals or ozone-depleting materials.
  • Pain Relief – Customers say the mattress has helped their back pain go away. Pocket coils and latex provide great lower back support.
  • Sleeps Cool – Organic latex is temperature neutral and never overheats. Pocket coils provide good airflow to keep sleepers cool.

Pros

  • Certified organic latex material
  • Split firmness available for couples
  • Great support and pressure relief

Cons

  • Heavy mattress due to latex material
  • Minimum 30-night break-in period
  • Customers say returns can be difficult
DreamCloud is a premium hybrid mattress with a durable, luxurious design. The mattress has a medium firmness that provides great comfort and support.
  • Quilted Cover – DreamCloud has a luxurious quilted Euro top cover. This gives a soft feel with plenty of cushioning.
  • Affordable Luxury – Customers think the mattress is a great value. Most people like the pocket coils, latex, and memory foam construction.
  • Great Comfort – The mattress mixes the benefits of foam with the support of pocket coils. This works well for different sleeping styles.

Pros

  • Affordable, luxury mattress in a box
  • Durable materials are strong and supportive
  • Good pressure relief and back support

Cons

  • Heavy mattress that is difficult to lift
  • No soft or firm options available
  • 15-inch height too tall for some people
Alexander Hybrid is a quality mattress made in the USA from durable materials. Pocket coils and premium foams keep heavy sleepers comfortable and supported.
  • No Weight Limit – Nest Bedding does not provide a weight limit for Alexander Hybrid. Most heavy people get great support on this mattress.
  • Comfort & Support – The mattress has a good mix of back support and pressure relief. Customers often mention a soft yet supportive feel.
  • Temperature Regulation – The hybrid design gives good airflow. Most customers say the mattress sleeps cool, even in warmer climates.

Pros

  • 3 firmness options (soft, medium, and firm)
  • Hybrid design keeps heavy people afloat
  • Good pressure relief and back support

Cons

  • Slight off-gassing smell (but goes away)
  • Heavy mattress that is hard to move
  • More expensive than some budget brands

Buying Guide For Innerspring Mattresses

Top 3 Shopping Tips For Innerspring Mattresses

Before buying an innerspring mattress, consider mattress firmness and sleeping position. Also be aware of innerspring and hybrid differences.

Consider Before Buying:

Innerspring Or Hybrid? – Traditional innerspring mattresses use interconnected coils. Hybrid mattresses use smaller, individually-wrapped pocket coils.

Mattress Firmness – Medium firmness works well for most people. But soft and firm options can help lightweight and heavier people.

Sleeping Position – Innerspring mattresses work best for back and stomach sleeping. But hybrid mattresses provide pressure relief for side sleepers.

Buyer’s Pro Tip

Andy David

Andy David

Choose a mattress that provides good back support and durability. This will prevent aches and pains. Side sleepers may need the pressure relief of a hybrid bed.

Andy David

Benefits Of Innerspring Mattresses

Innerspring mattresses have a different feel than memory foam and latex beds. Shoppers should be aware of these before buying.

Bounce & Response: Innerspring mattresses are more responsive and bouncy. They are a popular choice for sexually active couples.

Firmer Support: Innerspring mattresses do not contour to the body like memory foam. There is more support but less pressure relief.

Strong Edge Support: Most innerspring beds have good edge support. This makes the mattress feel bigger for couples.

Temperature Regulation: Innerspring mattresses have good airflow. Coils allow air to flow freely throughout the mattress.

Choosing Innerspring Mattress Firmness

The right firmness depends on body weight, favorite sleeping position, and personal preferences.

Most average weight sleepers enjoy medium firmness. Combination sleepers who switch positions also find medium firmness comfortable.

Lightweight people prefer softer mattresses. Heavy people often need a firmer bed.

Swipe left to view more

Sleeping Position

Light Body Weight

Average Body Weight

Heavy Body Weight

Side Sleeper

Soft

Medium

Medium or Medium-Firm

Back Sleeper

Soft or Medium

Medium or Medium-Firm

Medium-Firm or Firm

Stomach Sleeper

Soft or Medium

Medium-Firm

Firm

Combination Sleeper

Medium

Medium or Medium-Firm

Medium-Firm or Firm

Innerspring Beds For Side Sleepers

Traditional innerspring mattresses are not good for side sleepers. The coils can cause aches and pains in the shoulders and hips.

Hybrid mattresses are a better choice for side sleepers who need extra support. Individually-wrapped coils also work well for heavy side sleepers.

Swipe left to view more

Side Sleeping Rating

 Not good
Some innerspring mattresses lack pressure relief. Side sleepers often get aches and pains in their hips and shoulders.
Memory foam cushions and conforms the curves of the body. This provides better pressure relief for the joints.

Innerspring Mattresses For Back Pain

Shoppers with back pain often find good support on innerspring beds. Back and stomach sleepers benefit most from innerspring mattresses.

But durability is key. Innerspring beds that sag can cause backache. So choose a mattress with proven durability.

Swipe left to view more

Back Pain Rating

 Excellent
 Good

Innerspring Mattresses For Heavy People

Heavy people often need the strong support that innerspring mattresses provide. Hybrid mattresses also work well to keep the body afloat.

But heavy side sleepers may prefer a hybrid bed with pocket coils and foam. This will provide good support and extra pressure relief.

Swipe left to view more

Heavy People Rating

 Excellent
 Good
Heavy back sleepers enjoy innerspring mattresses. They keep the hips and abdomen afloat to prevent back pain.
Memory foam can lack support for heavy people. The body can sink too far down, causing backache.

Frequently asked questions

It depends on personal preferences. Memory foam hugs the body and provides good pressure relief. Innerspring mattresses have better support and bounce.

Innerspring mattresses work well for many people. Especially back and stomach sleepers. Side sleepers find innerspring beds cause aches and pains.

More coils generally mean the mattress has better durability and pressure relief. But do not judge the quality of mattress on coil count alone.

Innerspring mattresses are not recommended for side sleepers. But hybrid beds with pocket coils provide good pressure relief for side sleeping.

Most innerspring mattresses have good edge support. This is important for couples who spread out in bed.

Traditional innersprings are interconnected and work together for support. Pocket coils are individually-wrapped and give better motion isolation and pressure relief.

A hybrid mattress uses a mixture of foams or latex and coils. Most hybrid mattresses found online are made from modern pocket coils.