HOMEaaBest Mattress 2019aaBest Firm Mattress (2019)

Helping mattress shoppers get the right mattress since 2016

Best Firm Mattress (2019)

See the expert's choice for best value, side sleepers and back pain
Andy David
Guide by Andy DavidUpdated September 2019

Our Review Process & Trust Policy

Our team researched and analyzed over 150,000 verified mattress customer reviews. We tested and sleep trialed mattresses to help with research. We’re committed to honesty and trust – showing you the truth about mattresses. This research is made possible by our readers. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research.

Quick Summary - Which is the best firm mattress?

To help you find the best firm mattress, we read over 150,000 genuine mattress customer reviews. Our top recommendations are based on verified customer reviews and our mattress testing.

If you need more information and details, below are reviews for each mattress.

Best Firm Mattress Reviews

DreamCloud is a luxury hybrid mattress with a medium-firm feel. Pocket coils, latex, and memory foam provide fantastic comfort and support.
  • Firm Support – DreamCloud is a luxurious mattress with a strong, supportive feel. The mattress has great support and comfort to all body weights.
  • Competitive Price – The mattress is competitively priced for a luxury hybrid. Customers think DreamCloud is a great value buy.
  • 365-Night Trial – Comes with a year-long trial period. This lets buyers try the mattress in the comfort of their home, risk-free.

Pros

  • Comfortable for most back and stomach sleepers
  • An affordable luxury hybrid mattress
  • High-quality materials and durable construction

Cons

  • Off-gassing smell (but this goes away)
  • A heavy mattress that is difficult to move
  • Delivery delays can happen during busy periods
Nest Alexander Hybrid is a great value mattress made from quality materials. Most customers report good pressure relief and back support.
  • Great Value – For the quality of materials, the price cannot be beaten. Customers are happy the mattress is durable and built to last.
  • Comfort & Support – Provides great levels of firm comfort and support. The mattress feels good for different body weights and sleeping positions.
  • Made In USA – Quality yet affordable mattress that is made in the USA. Nest is an established company that receives positive customer reviews.

Pros

  • Great value for a luxury hybrid mattress
  • Split firmness options available for couples
  • Strong edge support due to pocket coils

Cons

  • Occasional delivery delays during busy periods
  • Minor off-gassing smell (goes away after a few days)
  • Unsuitable for buyers who like a memory foam feel
novosbed-mattress
Novosbed is a well-made foam mattress that provides great comfort for side sleepers. The company offers free firmness adjustments for customers.
  • Good Pressure Relief – Side sleepers get good protection for the hips and shoulders. This relieves pressure and minimizes aches and pains.
  • Comfort Adjustments – Novosbed give buyers free comfort adjustments during the trial period. Side sleepers can fine-tune the firmness to suit their needs.
  • Customer Service – Customers report good experiences with customer services. People say the company is proactive when dealing with queries.

Pros

  • High-density foams are supportive for side sleeping
  • 3 firmness options for side sleepers of different weights
  • Sleeps cooler than some memory foam mattresses

Cons

  • Too firm for some lightweight side sleepers
  • Bit more expensive than budget brands
  • 30-night minimum trial period before refund
Layla is an affordable memory foam mattress with dual-firmness. Customers can flip the mattress over to find the ideal level of back support.
  • Dual-Firmness – The firm side works well for people with back pain. Customers get good lumbar support and spinal alignment. But they can choose softer if needed.
  • Good Pain Relief – Many customer reviews mention pain relief. People say their back pain went away after using Layla.
  • Copper-Infused Foam – The mattress is made from copper-infused memory foam. This sleeps cool and provides healing benefits (good for back pain).

Pros

  • Many customer reports of back pain relief
  • Above average edge support for memory foam
  • USA-made with an affordable price point

Cons

  • Can be difficult to find the perfect firmness
  • Off-gassing smell (but soon goes away)
  • Benefits of copper-infused foam may be limited
saatva-mattress
Saatva is a high-quality hybrid mattress made in the USA from many layers. The mattress is a good choice for buyers who want a firm, supportive feel.
  • Firm Support – 3 firmness options are available. But even the softest option is firmer than usual. This provides plenty of choice for buyers who like a firm mattress.
  • Hybrid Design – Combines foam, pocket coils, and innersprings. The mattress has reliable support for stomach sleepers and heavy people.
  • Great Durability – Saatva is a durable mattress made from quality materials. The company says their mattress should last 10 to 15 years.

Pros

  • Pocket coils give firm support and stability
  • Free white glove delivery (with old mattress removal)
  • Tall 14-inch option for increased support

Cons

  • A little more expensive than budget brands
  • Rare reports of mattress losing its firmness
  • Extra cost for returns within 120-night trial period
Nest Alexander is a luxury memory foam mattress with dual-firmness. It is made from high-density foams and provides firm, supportive comfort.
  • Dual-Firmness – Provides two firmness options in one. The firm side has a comfortable feel to suit most back and stomach sleepers.
  • Cooling Foam – Copper and gel-infused foam provides pressure relief and sleeps cool. This is unlike standard memory foam that traps heat.
  • Made In USA – The mattress is made in the USA from premium memory foam. Customers say the mattress is competitively priced and cheaper than in-store brands.

Pros

  • A quality memory foam mattress with great support
  • CertiPUR-US foams are non-toxic and eco-friendly
  • People say the customer service team is helpful

Cons

  • Couples can struggle to find the perfect firmness
  • Customers say memory foam material can sleep hot
  • Heavy mattress that can be difficult to flip over
brooklyn-bedding-signature-mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature is a competitively priced hybrid mattress. Customers who like a luxurious yet solid feel will enjoy the firm option.
  • Comfort & Support – Ideal for buyers who want pressure relief but a firm, supportive feel. Brooklyn Signature provides a hotel bed experience at an affordable price.
  • Bounce & Response – The pocket coils provide plenty of bounce and response. Couples who toss and turn also get good motion isolation.
  • Durable Design – Brooklyn Signature is made in the USA from quality materials. Most customers say the mattress feels solid and well-built.

Pros

  • Pocket coils give support for different body weights
  • Hybrid design improves airflow and cooling
  • Quality, comfort, and affordable pricing

Cons

  • Motion isolation is good but could be better
  • Some customers say the mattress sleeps hot
  • 30-night minimum trial period before refund
avocado-green-mattress
Avocado Green is a comfortable and supportive hybrid mattress. It has a firm feel and is made from 100% natural latex and pocket coils.
  • Natural Materials – The mattress is made from natural latex, organic cotton, and wool. Avocado Green is GreenGuard Gold certified and contains no toxic chemicals.
  • Solid Support – Responsive latex and pocket coils keep the body afloat. Customers enjoy good back support and pressure relief.
  • Back Pain Relief – Many customers say the mattress has solved their back pain. Firm latex and pocket coils work well to keep the back supported.

Pros

  • Pressure relief with a responsive, firm feel
  • Natural materials are good for allergy sufferers
  • 25-year manufacturer warranty

Cons

  • A heavy bed that is difficult to move around
  • Slight off-gassing smell (non-toxic and goes away)
  • Side sleepers can find the mattress too firm
plushbeds-botanical-bliss-mattress
Botanical Bliss is an organic latex mattress that gives good support for heavy people. It provides solid, firm support that keeps the body afloat.
  • Great Support – Organic latex provides good pressure relief and back support. Heavy people will never sink too far into the mattress.
  • Durable Construction – Made in the USA from layers of certified organic latex. Plus size people think the mattress is durable and built to last.
  • Competitive Price – Botanical Bliss is an organic latex mattress at a great value price. It’s affordable and cheaper than in-store latex beds.

Pros

  • 100% organic latex is supportive and sleeps cool
  • 3 different height options for heavy people
  • Split firmness options available for couples

Cons

  • Heavy mattress that needs two people to move
  • Plus size customers may need better edge support
  • Return pickups are curbside only (can be problematic)

Best Firm Mattress Buying Guide

Top 3 Shopping Tips For Best Firm Mattress

Before buying a firm mattress, consider body weight, sleeping positions, and mattress materials.

Consider Before Buying:

Body Weight – Firm mattresses work best with heavier body weights. But some lighter back and stomach sleepers enjoy a firm feel.

Sleeping Positions – A firm mattress is most comfortable for back and stomach sleepers. But some heavy side sleepers may need a firm mattress.

Mattress Materials – Memory foam, latex, and hybrids feel different. Be aware of the differences between materials before buying a mattress.

Buyer’s Pro Tip

Andy David

Andy David

Firm mattresses are not for everyone. Shoppers should choose a mattress that suits their body weight and favorite sleeping position.

Andy David

Body Weight & Sleeping Styles For Firm Mattresses

Firm mattresses are most comfortable for heavy weight sleepers. But some average weight sleepers also enjoy a firm feel.

Sleeping styles are important to consider. Firm mattresses work best for back and stomach sleeping. Side sleepers often need a bit more cushioning.

Side Sleepers: Firm beds are not ideal for side sleeping. But heavy people may need a firmer mattress due to extra body weight.

Back Sleepers: Average and heavy back sleepers get good support from firmer mattresses. Lightweight individuals may need a softer feel.

Stomach Sleepers: Firm mattresses work best for stomach sleeping. They keep the hips afloat to prevent back pain.

Swipe left to view more

Sleeping Position

Light Body Weight

Average Body Weight

Heavy Body Weight

Side Sleeper

Soft

Medium

Medium-Firm

Back Sleeper

Soft or Medium

Medium or Medium-Firm

Medium-Firm or Firm

Stomach Sleeper

Medium

Firm

Medium-Firm or Firm

Combination Sleeper

Medium

Medium-Firm

Firm

Firm mattresses can work well for heavier people. They stop key body areas from sinking too far down.
Soft mattresses can cause the body to sink too far into the bed. This can throw the spine out of alignment.

Best Firm Mattress For Back Pain

Shoppers with back pain need lower back support and neutral spine alignment. This minimizes pain and improves sleep quality.

Body weight and sleeping position are key factors to consider. A mattress that is too firm will cause back pain. So will a bed that is too soft.

It is important the mattress conforms to the lower back. This keeps the spine aligned to prevent back pain.
An extra firm mattress can be too firm for some people. There is not enough “give” in the mattress to support the spine.

Best Firm Mattress Types

Buyers should consider different materials when choosing a mattress. Each mattress type has a different level of comfort and support.

Memory Foam: Contours to the body for pressure relief and back support. Memory foam is slower to respond and sometimes sleeps hot.

Latex: A responsive material that sleeps cool and provides plenty of support. Latex provides pressure relief but is more expensive than foam.

Hybrids: Hybrid mattresses are made from foam or latex and pocket coils. They offer pressure relief, bounce, and good back support.

Trial Periods & Warranty Information

Shoppers wanting a firm mattress should consider trial periods and warranties. Most online mattress brands offer generous trial and warranty periods.

Trials allow buyers to try the mattress at home, risk-free. Customers can return the mattress if needed for a refund (often free).

Warranty periods cover manufacturing and material faults. Lifetime warranties are often prorated after a number of years. So be aware of this.

Swipe left to view more

Mattress Brand

Trial Period

Warranty Period

365-night

Lifetime warranty

100-night

Lifetime warranty

120-night

15-year warranty

120-night

Lifetime warranty

120-night

15-year warranty

100-night

Lifetime warranty

120-night

10-year warranty

100-night

25-year warranty

100-night

25-year warranty

Frequently asked questions

Firm mattresses are usually too firm for side sleeping. This is because side sleepers need good pressure point relief. But heavy side sleepers may need a firmer mattress.

An extra firm mattress will be too firm for most people. But it depends on body weight and personal preferences. Some heavy people may need extra firm support.

This depends on body weight, sleeping position, and personal preferences. Lightweight people usually prefer soft. Heavy weight people like firmer mattresses.

There is no perfect mattress because every person is different. But the best extra firm mattress will provide good back support and pressure relief.

Firm mattresses will soften over time. But the amount they soften depends on the materials and quality of construction. Memory foam usually softens the quickest.

Sleeping on a firm bed is not always good for back pain. But it depends on body weight and sleeping position. Stomach and back sleepers may need a firm mattress. But side sleepers and lightweight people should consider softer options.