This research is made possible by our readers. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research
HOMEaaBest Pillows 2019aaBrooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow Review

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow Review

Andy David
Review by Andy David
Pillow expert Updated Oct 2019

Our Review Process

Our team researched and analyzed over 1,837 verified Brooklyn Shredded Foam pillow customer reviews. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research.

Quick Overview

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow is a great value, quality pillow with adjustable loft. It has good cooling features and supports different sleeping styles.

But there is a strong off-gassing smell at first. Some people say the pillow does not cool as well as advertised.

  • Good – Fluffy yet supportive pillow with medium firmness and adjustable loft.
  • Bad – Strong smell on unboxing. Some heavy side sleepers need better support.
  • Buy or not – Buy for a great value, quality foam pillow with customizable loft. Shoppers who prefer a firmer feel should consider other brands.

Pros

  • Competitive price tag ($44+)
  • Works for all sleeping positions
  • Adjustable loft (the cover unzips)
  • Many reports of neck pain relief
  • Machine washable cover

Cons

  • Off-gassing smell (but goes away)
  • Messy loft customization process
  • Lumpy texture often needs re-fluffing
  • Stomach sleepers must remove lots of fill
  • Some reports that the pillow sleeps hot

Lowest Pricefor Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow customer ratings

Category

Rating

Customer Experience Summary

Comfort

 Excellent

Most customers enjoy the fluffy, supportive feel. But many people need to customize the level of fill

Quality

 Good

Customers say the pillow is well-made and durable. There are few reports about manufacturing or material defects

Value

 Good

Many people think the pillow is a great value buy. The price is cheaper than many competitor brands

Cooling

 Good

Customers report good temperature regulation. But a few people say the pillow sleeps hot

Side Sleepers

 Excellent

Side sleepers like good neck support and body alignment. Most customers report great comfort in this position

Neck & Back Pain

 Excellent

Customers with neckache say the pillow reduces pain. There are many reports of neck pain relief in all sleeping positions

Firmness & Height Options

 Excellent

Most people are happy with the adjustable loft. Although a few customers say removing the fill is a messy process

Smell/Off-gassing

 Not good

Many customers report an off-gassing smell on unboxing. This can take a few days to disappear

Cleaning

 Good

Customers like the machine washable cover. But a few people would prefer a fully washable pillow

Returns & Warranty

 Good

Most people say the returns process is straightforward. The 3-year warranty is also better than many competitor brands

Lifespan

 Good

Customers like durable materials. Most people get at least 2 to 3 years of use

Company Reputation

 Good

Brooklyn Bedding has a great reputation. Most people report good customer service

Everything you need to know about Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow

Soft & Cozy Feel Provides Comfort For All Body Weights

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow has a fluffy yet supportive feel. The pillow provides good support for different body weights.

Customers can unzip the cover to customize the loft. Many customers need to remove or add to the fill.

Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
 Good

Heavy people get decent support when side and back sleeping. But stomach sleepers need to remove plenty of fill

Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
 Excellent

The pillow works best for average body weights. It provides good neck support and spinal alignment

Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
 Good

Lightweight sleepers enjoy the fluffy yet supportive feel. Especially lightweight side sleepers

Great Quality, Durable Materials - And A Machine Washable Cover

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow has high-quality, durable construction. The design features a machine washable zippable cover.

  • Removable Cover – A machine washable, charcoal-bamboo blend cover. Antimicrobial and breathable to help with cooling.
  • Shredded Foam Fill – A mixture of deconstructed memory foam and proprietary cooling foam. Provides a fluffy yet supportive feel that contours to the head and neck.

Adjustable Loft That Works For All Sleeping Positions

The pillow has an adjustable loft that provides support for all sleeping positions. Out of the box, it works best for side and back sleepers.

Side sleepers
Side sleepers
Side sleepers
 Excellent

Most side sleepers are happy with the level of support. But some people would like a firmer feel and taller loft

Back sleepers
Back sleepers
Back sleepers
 Good

Back sleepers like the customizable loft. Most people can get perfect neck and spinal alignment

Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
 Good

Many stomach sleepers need to lower the loft. Often up to 50% of the filling for good neck support

Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
 Good

Combo sleepers get good all-around support. But the pillow works best for side and back sleeping

Trial Period And Full Warranty Details

Sleep trial

120-Night

Refund

Full

Warranty

3-Year

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow has a 3-year limited warranty. This covers material and manufacturing defects only.

Most customers get around 2 to 3 years of comfortable use. The pillow keeps its shape well. But it may need fluffing-up from time to time.

Risk-Free Trial Details

  • 120-night risk-free trial period
  • Company will provide a full refund
  • Free return shipping is available

Warranty Details 

  • 3-year limited warranty
  • Covers manufacturing and material defects
  • Company will repair or replace a defective pillow

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow Positive Customer Reviews

Most customers report great comfort and support on Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow. People like cooling features and neck pain relief.

  • Neck Pain Relief – Many customers like how the pillow relieves neck pain. Most people say their neck was well-supported after customizing the fill.
  • Soft & Snuggly – Customers say the pillow feels fluffy and snuggly. People enjoy how the pillow contours to the neck and head.
  • Great Cooling – Most customers report good temperature regulation. People who usually overheat say the pillow keeps them cool.

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow Customer Complaints

There are few negative reviews about Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow. Most complaints mention the strong off-gassing odor.

  • Strong Off-Gassing Odor – Customers say there is a strong odor on unboxing. This can take up to one week to completely disappear.
  • Goes Flatter Over Time – Some customers complain about the pillow going flatter over time. But re-fluffing the pillow regularly helps.
  • Too Much Loft – A few people report too much loft out of the box. But customizable loft means customers can get the perfect feel.

Shipping

Shipping Method

Ships by FedEx

Pillow Care

Machine wash the cover only. Air dry or tumble dry on a low heat

  • Ships by FedEx. Delivery within 3 to 8 days
  • Free shipping to the contiguous USA
  • Alaska and Hawaii shipping costs extra

  • Machine wash the cover only
  • Air dry or tumble dry on low heat
  • Do not machine wash the entire pillow

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow Prices

The pillow is competitively priced and available in Queen and King sizes. Queen-size costs $44 and King-size costs $49.

Swipe left to view more

Size

Price

Queen

King

Where Is The Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow Made?

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow is made in the USA. Only good quality, durable materials are used in the construction.

Brooklyn Bedding is an established online bedding brand. The company sells a range of mattresses and accessories.

Fast & Easy Setup - But There Is An Odor At First

The pillow ships rolled up in a box. Customers can use it straight away after unboxing.

But most people report a strong odor at first. This can take a few days to fully disappear.

Should You Buy A Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow?

Shoppers wanting a fluffy yet supportive pillow should consider Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow. It has a washable cover, adjustable loft, and good cooling.

But there is a strong off-gassing smell on unboxing. Stomach sleepers or people who like flat, firm pillows should consider other brands.

Consider Before Buying:

  • Soft & Supportive Feel – The pillow has a fluffy yet supportive feel that contours to the head and neck. It works best for people who like softer, conforming pillows.
  • Adjustable Loft – Customers can unzip the cover and remove the fill. This allows people to customize the feel.
  • Off-Gassing Smell – There is a strong off-gassing smell at first. Customers say this can take up to a week to fully disappear.

Frequently Asked Questions

The pillow comes in Queen and King sizes only. There is no Standard size currently available.

Side sleepers report good neck support and spinal alignment. But a few people need a pillow with a higher loft.

Most customers say the pillow has great cooling. There are few reports about overheating.

The pillow has a medium firmness. This works well for most sleeping styles.

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow has an average loft. About 4 or 5 inches.

Many customers say their neck pain disappeared. The adjustable loft means people can find the perfect feel.

The cover is a charcoal-bamboo blend. The fill is made with shredded pieces of proprietary memory foam.

Brooklyn Bedding uses CertiPUR-US certified foams. This shows the foam materials have low toxicity.

The pillow is made in the USA from quality materials. Brooklyn Bedding runs a dedicated factory.

Most customers get at least 2 to 3 years of use. This is normal for most high-quality foam pillows.

There is a strong off-gassing smell on unboxing. This can take a few days to go away.

The company provides a 120-night risk-free trial. Customers can request a full refund during this time.

Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow review summary

Overall rating

4.5 out of 5
4.5 out of 5
Andy David
Rated & Review by Andy David
Comfort
 Excellent
Quality
 Good
Value
 Good
Side Sleepers
 Excellent
Neck & Back Pain
 Excellent
Cooling
 Good
Smell/Off-gassing
 Not good
Company Reputation
 Good

Good

Fluffy yet supportive pillow with medium firmness and adjustable loft.

Bad

Strong smell on unboxing. Some heavy side sleepers need better support.

Buy or not

Buy for a great value, quality foam pillow with customizable loft. Shoppers who prefer a firmer feel should consider other brands.

Where To Buy The Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow?

The best place to buy the Brooklyn Shredded Foam pillow is on the official website. Click the button below to get the lowest price.

Lowest Pricefor Brooklyn Shredded Foam Pillow

About the author

Andy David
Andy David Mattress expert

Andy is the chief editor at Sleep Cupid. Andy researches and reviews leading mattress brands to help our readers get the right mattress and enjoy better rest.