HOMEaaMattress Reviews 2019aaBrooklyn Bedding Reviews

Helping mattress shoppers get the right mattress since 2016

Brooklyn Bedding Reviews

The good, the bad and everything in between
Andy David
Reviewed by Andy DavidUpdated September 2019

Our Review Process & Trust Policy

Our team researched and analyzed over 150,000 verified mattress customer reviews. We tested and sleep trialed mattresses to help with research. We’re committed to honesty and trust – showing you the truth about mattresses. This research is made possible by our readers. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research.

Quick Overview - Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Choices

Most Popular
  • Excellent Cooling: Cooling foams and hybrid design provides great temperature regulation.
  • 3 Firmness Options: A choice of 3 firmness options: soft, medium, firm.
  • All Sleeping Positions: Great comfort and support for all sleeping positions.
brooklyn-bedding-signature-mattress
  • Affordable Luxury: A great value mattress made from premium foams and pocket coils.
  • Back Pain Relief: Many customers report good back pain relief.
  • Comfort & Support: Hybrid design gives a mixture of pressure relief and back support.
  • Budget-Friendly: Affordable foam mattress perfect for shoppers on a budget.
  • Quality Materials: High-quality foams are durable and made to last.
  • Made In USA: USA construction in a dedicated mattress factory.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Good selection of mattresses for different budgets.
  • Quality USA construction with great value prices.
  • Many size options and firmness levels to choose from.
  • Dedicated mattress factory for great quality control.
  • 10-year non-prorated warranty on all models.

Cons

  • Most models have an off-gassing smell at first.
  • 30-night minimum trial makes returns more difficult.
  • Alaska and Hawaii shipping available from $125.
  • Some reports of poor customer service (although rare).
  • Delivery delays can occur during busy periods.

Which Brooklyn Bedding mattress is right for me

Price$ 1,699/Queen
Weight105 lbs
TypeHybrid
Firmness4,6,8
Trial120 nights
Warranty10 years

Category

Rating

What users are saying

Comfort

 Excellent

Most customers find Aurora comfortable. The mattress is excellent at reducing pain

Quality

 Excellent

Customers say the mattress is fantastic quality, durable and solid

Value

 Good

People are happy buying a luxury mattress at an affordable price

Cooling

 Excellent

Customers think Aurora provides amazing cooling even in warm weather

Side Sleepers

 Excellent

Customers who side sleep experience excellent pressure relief in the shoulders and hips

Back Pain

 Good

Many customers report less back pain. But the bed can be too soft for some people

Smell/Off-gassing

 Not good

Some customers get a strong smell after unboxing. This goes after a while

Edge support

 Excellent

Customers enjoy best-in-class edge support. Lying or sitting on the bed is ultra supportive

Couples

 Good

Great edge support and motion isolation makes Aurora a good choice for couples

Company reputation

 Good

Overall Brooklyn has a good reputation. But complaints appear from time to time

brooklyn-bedding-signature-mattress
Price$ 949/Queen
Weight105 lbs
TypeHybrid
Firmness4,6,8
Trial120 nights
Warranty10 years

Category

Rating

What users are saying

Comfort

 Good

Most customers report good comfort. But people find some firmness options more comfortable than others

Quality

 Excellent

Customers say the mattress is well-made using high-quality materials

Value

 Good

Many customers comment on the great value. Customers like the affordable price point

Cooling

 Good

Some customers mention the mattress sleeps cool. But a few people find it sleeps hot

Side Sleepers

 Good

The medium option suits side sleepers best. Many report that the firm version is too hard for side sleeping

Back Pain

 Good

Most customers say the mattress helps with back pain. But a few customers think the mattress is too soft or too firm

Smell/Off-gassing

 Excellent

Most people report little or no odor after unpacking

Edge support

 Good

The edge support is good for most people. Heavier customers find it less supportive

Couples

 Good

Couples enjoy the comfort and support. But it can be difficult to find the ideal firmness

Company reputation

 Good

Customers think Brooklyn has a strong reputation and gives great customer service

Price$ 699/Queen
Weight70 lbs
TypeMemory Foam
Firmness5.5
Trial120 nights
Warranty10 years

Category

Rating

What users are saying

Comfort

 Good

Customers find the mattress best for back and side sleeping. People say the foam is responsive and gives good support

Quality

 Good

Many customers think the quality is good. They also like how the mattress is made in the USA

Value

 Excellent

Most customers mention great value. The mattress is one of the most affordable on the market

Cooling

 Good

There are few reports of overheating. Most people say the mattress sleeps cool

Side Sleepers

 Excellent

Side sleepers enjoy the mattress most. They get good pressure relief for the hips and shoulders

Back Pain

 Good

Many back sleepers say their backache went away. But some people find the bed too soft

Smell/Off-gassing

 Excellent

Most customers report no off-gassing. There are few reports of any lingering smell

Edge support

 Not good

Customers think the edge support is average at best. It works okay for most people

Couples

 Good

Couples like the all-around comfortable feel and response. But the medium firmness does not suit everybody

Company reputation

 Good

Overall the reputation is good. But there are reports of poor customer service. This impacts on the Brooklyn brand