This research is made possible by our readers. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research
HOMEaaBest Pillows 2019aaBrooklinen Down Pillow Review

Brooklinen Down Pillow Review

Andy David
Review by Andy David
Pillow expert Updated Oct 2019

Our Review Process

Our team researched and analyzed over 1,048 verified Brooklinen Down pillow customer reviews. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research.

Quick Overview

Down Pillow is a fluffy yet supportive pillow available in 3 firmness options. It has a down and feather fill and a competitive price.

But customers say the pillow needs regular re-fluffing. There may be too much loft for some back and stomach sleepers.

  • Good – Great quality and good for sleepers who like down but need extra support.
  • Bad – Too expensive for shoppers on a budget. Cannot be machine washed.
  • Buy or not – Buy for a quality, supportive pillow with a down-like feel. Shoppers on a budget or who need low loft should avoid.

Pros

  • Fluffy down feel with good support
  • Great value, good quality pillow
  • 3 options (plush, mid-plush, firm)
  • Lifetime warranty and free returns
  • Antimicrobial and hypoallergenic

Cons

  • Too firm for some types of sleeper
  • Needs regular re-fluffing to stay in shape
  • Dry clean only (not machine washable)
  • Rare reports of poor customer service
  • Down sleeps too hot for some people

Lowest Pricefor Brooklinen Down Pillow

Brooklinen Down Pillow customer ratings

Category

Rating

Customer Experience Summary

Comfort

 Good

Most customers say the pillow is soft yet supportive. But it needs fluffing up regularly

Quality

 Good

Customers report good quality and durability. There are few reports about defective materials

Value

 Good

Many people think the pillow is a great value. But it is more expensive than budget brands

Cooling

 Not good

Customers say the pillow overheats at times. It works better in cooler climates

Side Sleepers

 Excellent

Most side sleepers think the pillow is soft and supportive. Customers report good body alignment and less neck pain

Neck & Back Pain

 Good

There are many reports of neck pain relief. But some people find the loft too tall

Firmness & Height Options

 Excellent

Customers like having 3 options to choose from. There are positive reports about the 100% satisfaction guarantee

Smell/Off-gassing

 Excellent

Most people do not report an off-gassing smell. Any slight odor soon goes away

Cleaning

 Not good

Some customers find dry clean only problematic. But a pillow protector can reduce the need for cleaning

Returns & Warranty

 Excellent

Most people are happy with the returns process. Customer reports about exchanges are also positive

Lifespan

 Good

Customers say the pillow is durable and lasts for at least 2 years. This is normal for most high-quality down pillows

Company Reputation

 Good

Brooklinen has a great reputation. Customer reviews are mostly positive

Everything you need to know about Brooklinen Down Pillow

Fluffy Feel Of A Down Pillow - With Added Support

Down Pillow comes in 3 firmness options: plush, mid-plush, and firm. The most popular model is mid-plush.

The pillow has the fluffy feel of down but with extra support. It works well for most body weights and sleeping styles.

Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
 Good

Most heavy sleepers find good comfort. Especially heavy side sleepers who need plenty of loft and support

Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
 Excellent

Average weight sleepers like the mid-plush option best. But a few people find the loft too tall

Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
 Good

Lightweight side sleepers prefer the mid-plush option. But the plush model works well for back and stomach sleeping

Good Quality, Durable Materials That Are Built To Last

Down Pillow is made from high-quality, ethically-sourced materials. The pillow is antimicrobial and hypoallergenic.

  • Cotton Cover – A soft, breathable cotton outer casing. This is double-stitched for extra durability.
  • Down Fill – The filling is Canadian white down. This provides a cozy, fluffy feel. The plush option is 100% down-filled.
  • Feather Core – The mid-plush and firm options also have a feather core. This gives a classic down feel with added support.

3 Firmness Options Work For All Sleeping Positions

3 firmness options provide comfort and support for different sleeping positions. Combo sleepers who switch positions enjoy the mid-plush option.

Side sleepers
Side sleepers
Side sleepers
 Excellent

Side sleepers like the pillow the most. Different body weights report good support in this position

Back sleepers
Back sleepers
Back sleepers
 Good

Mid-plush works well for most back sleepers. It provides good support and neck alignment

Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
 Good

Stomach sleepers find the plush option most comfortable. The loft on the firmer options is too high

Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
 Good

Combo sleepers find decent comfort on the mid-plush option. But the loft can be too tall for some customers

Trial Period And Full Warranty Details

Sleep trial

365-Night

Refund

Full

Warranty

Lifetime Warranty

Down Pillow comes with a lifetime warranty. Brooklinen will replace pillows with material or manufacturing defects.

Most customers will get around 2 to 3 years of comfortable use. The pillow keeps its shape well during this time. But it needs regular re-fluffing.

Risk-Free Trial Details

  • 365-night risk-free trial period
  • Full refund or exchange available
  • Free return shipping to most of the USA

Warranty Details

  • Lifetime manufacturer warranty
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Free exchanges and replacements

Brooklinen Down Pillow Positive Customer Reviews

Most customers think Down Pillow is comfortable and supportive. People like the fluffy cloud-like feel and great service.

  • Soft & Supportive – Most customers enjoy the soft yet supportive feel. People say the pillow works well for their favorite sleeping position.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee – People who want a softer or firmer feel can get a free replacement. People are happy with the free exchange service.
  • Great Value – Customers think the pillow is a great value for the quality of materials. People say the pillow is better than similar-priced competitors.

Brooklinen Down Pillow Customer Complaints

Down Pillow has few complaints. But some customers say the pillow is too firm.

  • Too Firm – The mid-plush and firm options are firmer than expected. Some customers would prefer a softer, classic down feel.
  • Goes Flat – Customers say the pillow goes flat after a period of use. It needs regular re-fluffing to keep its shape.
  • Dry Clean Only – The pillow is dry clean only. Customers can find it difficult to keep clean. But a pillow protector helps.

Shipping

Shipping Method

Ships by courier

Pillow Care

Dry clean only for best results. Avoid machine washing and tumble drying

  • Ships by courier. Delivery within 3 to 5 business days
  • Free shipping on all pillow options
  • Free return shipping for warranty claims

  • Dry cleaning is recommended
  • Avoid machine washing and drying
  • Dry clean or wash only if necessary

Brooklinen Down Pillow Prices

Down Pillow has a competitive price compared to other quality brands. Customers can choose from standard and king size options.

Mid-plush and firm options begin at $69. Plush options begin at $99.

Swipe left to view more

Size

Dimensions

Support

Price

Standard

20W″x26L″

Plush

Standard

20W″x26L″

Mid-Plush

Standard

20W″x26L″

Firm

King

20W″x36L″

Plush

King

20W″x36L″

Mid-Plush

King

20W″x36L″

Firm

Where Is The Brooklinen Down Pillow Made?

The pillow is made in Canada from quality materials. Brooklinen also sells a range of bedding accessories.

This includes sheets, pillowcases, loungewear, and more. Most customers are happy with the quality of construction.

Use The Pillow Straight Away After Unboxing

Customers can use Down Pillow straight away after unboxing. Just fluff-up the pillow after unpacking.

Some people say there is a slight odor at first. Placing the pillow in a ventilated room will help the smell to go away.

Should You Buy A Brooklinen Down Pillow?

Shoppers who like down-filled pillows should consider Down Pillow. It has a fluffy yet supportive feel and a competitive price.

But the pillow is more expensive than budget options. It needs regular re-fluffing. And the loft is too tall for some people.

Consider Before Buying:

  • 3 Firmness Options – Down Pillow comes in 3 firmness/loft options. The plush option has 100% down fill (no feather core).
  • Firmer Than Expected – Customers say the mid-plush and firm options are firmer than expected. People wanting a classic down feel should choose the plush model.
  • Dry Cleaning Recommended – Customers should dry clean the pillow if possible. Avoid machine washing and tumble drying

Frequently Asked Questions

Down Pillow is available in standard and king size options. Prices start from $69.

The pillow works well for side sleepers. Customers report good neck support and body alignment.

The pillow can overheat in warm weather. Shoppers who sleep hot should consider other brands.

Down Pillow is available in 3 firmness options: plush, mid-plush, and firm. Mid-plush and firm are firmer than expected.

The mid-plush (most popular) option has an 8-inch loft. This goes down to around 4-inch during use.

The pillow does help with neck pain. But it is important for customers to choose the right firmness option.

Down Pillow is made from a cotton cover and down fill. The mid-plush and firm options also have a feather core.

The pillow has an antimicrobial and hypoallergenic treatment. This meets strict safety regulations. The company has many safety certifications.

Down Pillow is made in Canada. High-quality, durable materials are used in the construction.

Most customers will get 2 to 3 years of use. But the pillow can last much longer.

Some customers report a slight odor. But this soon disappears after a few days.

Brooklinen provides free return shipping. Refunds and free exchanges are available.

Brooklinen Down Pillow review summary

Overall rating

4.2 out of 5
4.2 out of 5
Andy David
Rated & Review by Andy David
Comfort
 Good
Quality
 Good
Value
 Good
Side Sleepers
 Excellent
Neck & Back Pain
 Good
Cooling
 Not good
Smell/Off-gassing
 Excellent
Company Reputation
 Good

Good

Great quality and good for sleepers who like down but need extra support.

Bad

Too expensive for shoppers on a budget. Cannot be machine washed.

Buy or not

Buy for a quality, supportive pillow with a down-like feel. Shoppers on a budget or who need low loft should avoid.

Where To Buy The Brooklinen Down Pillow?

The best place to buy the Brooklinen Down pillow is on the official website. Click the button below to get the lowest price.

Lowest Pricefor Brooklinen Down Pillow

About the author

Andy David
Andy David Mattress expert

Andy is the chief editor at Sleep Cupid. Andy researches and reviews leading mattress brands to help our readers get the right mattress and enjoy better rest.