This research is made possible by our readers. When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research
HOMEaaBest Pillows 2019aaBrooklinen Down Alternative Pillow Review

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow Review

Andy David
Review by Andy David
Pillow expert Updated Oct 2019

Our Review Process

Our team researched and analyzed over 467 verified Brooklinen Down Alternative pillow customer reviews.When readers use our links to make a purchase, we receive referral fees that fund our research.

Quick Overview

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow is a great value pillow made from cotton and microfiber. It feels like natural down and keeps its shape.

But some people find the loft too high. Customers on a budget should consider other brands. 

  • Good – Good value, down-like pillow with a 365-night risk-free trial period. 
  • Bad – Affordable, but not a budget brand. The pillow is dry clean only.
  • Buy or not – Buy for a supportive, microfiber pillow that feels like classic down. Customers wanting genuine down or a thinner loft should avoid.

Pros

  • Needs less fluffing than natural down
  • Cozy, fluffy feel that keeps its shape
  • Hypoallergenic and antimicrobial
  • Made from vegan-friendly materials
  • 3 options (plush, mid-plush, firm)

Cons

  • Affordable, but not a budget brand
  • Too much loft for some petite sleepers
  • Dry clean only (avoid machine washing)
  • Non-adjustable microfiber filling
  • Some reports about bad customer service

Lowest Pricefor Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow customer ratings

Category

Rating

Customer Experience Summary

Comfort

 Good

Many customers find the pillow comfortable. But some people say the loft is too high

Quality

 Good

Customers think the pillow has a luxurious, durable feel. Most people say the quality is good for the price

Value

 Good

Most customers say the pillow is a great value. It is affordable and better quality than many competitors

Cooling

 Good

Some customers find the pillow sleeps hot. But most people have no issue with the temperature regulation

Side Sleepers

 Excellent

Side sleepers get the best comfort from the pillow. It supports the neck and upper body well

Neck & Back Pain

 Good

Many customers say their neck pain went away. But some people think the loft causes neck pain

Firmness & Height Options

 Good

Customers are happy with the 3 firmness options. But a few people would prefer adjustable fill

Smell/Off-gassing

 Excellent

Most people do not report a lingering smell. Any odor goes away quickly

Cleaning

 Not good

Customers can only dry clean the pillow. Some people would prefer a fully washable pillow

Returns & Warranty

 Excellent

The returns process is easy for most customers. Brooklinen provide free returns and exchanges

Lifespan

 Good

Most customers say the pillow keeps its shape well. It does not need re-fluffing like many pillows

Company Reputation

 Excellent

Brooklinen has a good reputation overall. Most customer reviews are positive

Everything you need to know about Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow

Feels Soft & Fluffy Like Down - But With Better Support

Brooklinen Down Alternative has a soft and fluffy feel much like down. But it keeps its shape better so customers don’t have to re-fluff.

3 firmness options are available: plush, mid-plush, and firm. This provides good comfort and support for different body weights.

Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
Heavy weight sleepers
 Good

Heavy side sleepers get good comfort on the mid-plush option. But heavy stomach sleepers need the plush model

Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
Average weight sleepers
 Excellent

Average weight sleepers like mid-plush the best. But back and stomach sleepers may need firmer or softer options

Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
Light weight sleepers
 Good

Lightweight back sleepers like the plush or firm option. But side sleepers enjoy mid-plush

Good Quality, Hypoallergenic Materials For Great Support

Brooklinen Down Alternative is made from durable, high-quality materials. The pillow keeps its shape and is 100% hypoallergenic.

  • Cotton Cover – A 400-thread cotton cover provides good breathability to keep sleepers cool. It is OEKO-TEX certified and has double-stitched edges to improve durability.
  • Microfiber Fill – The 100% shaved microfiber fill feels soft and fluffy. It does not need regular re-fluffing like natural down pillows.

Best For Side Sleepers - And Some Back & Stomach Sleepers

Customers say the pillow works best for side sleepers. But combo sleepers also rate the pillow highly.

Side sleepers
Side sleepers
Side sleepers
 Excellent

Side sleepers get the best support on the mid-plush option. Customers say the pillow keeps the neck and body in good alignment

Back sleepers
Back sleepers
Back sleepers
 Good

Most back sleepers prefer the firm option best. It is not too tall and not too thin. But some people prefer a plush feel

Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
Stomach Sleepers
 Good

Stomach sleepers find decent support on the plush option. It keeps the neck and spine in good alignment

Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
Combination Sleepers
 Good

Mid-plush is best for combo sleepers. But some people find the loft too tall for back and stomach sleeping

Trial Period And Full Warranty Details

Sleep trial

365-Night

Refund

Full

Warranty

Lifetime Warranty

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow has a lifetime warranty. Customers with defective pillows can claim a free replacement.

The pillow keeps its shape well and should last 2 to 3 years. This is about average for quality microfiber pillows.

Risk-Free Trial Details

  • 365-night risk-free trial period
  • Free exchange or full refund
  • Return shipping is free of charge

Warranty Details

  • Lifetime warranty (best in industry)
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Brooklinen will provide a free replacement

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow Positive Customer Reviews

Overall customers are happy with Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow. People enjoy the soft yet supportive feel and great value price.

  • Cozy Support – Most customers say the pillow has a cozy, fluffy feel. But it also has enough support for different sleeping positions.
  • Neck Pain Relief – Customers find they have less neck pain. People say the pillow helps to keep the neck in good alignment.
  • Competitive Price – Most people think the price is affordable compared to competitors. Customers report good durability for the price.

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow Customer Complaints

Most customers like Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow. But there are a few complaints to consider.

  • Overstuffed Fill – Some customers think the fill is overstuffed. This can cause neck pain for some types of sleeper.
  • Dry Clean Only – A few people do not like how the pillow is “dry clean only”. Some customers would prefer a fully washable pillow.
  • Overpriced – People on a budget think the pillow is overpriced. Shoppers can find similar, more affordable pillows.

Shipping

Shipping Method

Ships by courier

Pillow Care

Dry clean only for best results. Avoid machine washing and tumble drying

  • Ships by courier (usually FedEx or UPS)
  • Free shipping within most of the USA
  • Delivery in 3 to 5 business days

  • Dry clean for best results
  • Avoid machine washing if possible
  • Do not tumble dry on high heat

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow Prices

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow is a great value, good quality pillow. Standard sizes are $59 and king sizes are $79.

Swipe left to view more

Size

Dimensions

Price

Standard

20W″x26L″

King

20W″x36L″

Where Is The Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow Made?

The pillow is made in the USA from quality materials. It is 100% hypoallergenic, antimicrobial, and vegan-friendly.

Brooklinen sells other bedding accessories. This includes bedsheets, loungewear, and blankets.

Fast & Easy Setup - There Are Usually No Odor Problems

Customers can use the pillow straight away after unboxing. There is no need to fluff-up before use.

There may be a slight smell after unboxing. Any smell is minor and soon disappears.

Should You Buy A Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow?

Shoppers wanting a hypoallergenic pillow should consider Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow. It feels similar to natural down but has better support.

But the mid-plush and firm pillow are too tall for some sleepers. Shoppers on a budget may find better value elsewhere.

Consider Before Buying:

  • Good For Allergy Sufferers – With microfiber fill, the pillow is good for people who are allergic to natural down. The pillow is also antimicrobial and vegan-friendly.
  • 3 Firmness Options – Customers can choose from 3 firmness options: plush, mid-plush, and firm. This works well for different sleeping positions.
  • Overstuffed Loft – Some people say there is too much loft on some firmness options. Back and stomach sleepers may need a thinner pillow.

Frequently Asked Questions

Customers can choose from a standard or king size. Standard size is $59 and king size is $79.

Side sleepers get great comfort and support. The pillow keeps the neck and spine in good alignment.

The pillow has average temperature regulation. It does not actively cool. But it does not get too warm either.

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow comes in 3 firmness options: plush, mid-plush, and firm. Some people say the firm option is firmer than expected.

The mid-plush pillow is about 6 inches tall on unboxing. It reduces to 3 or 4 inches during use.

There are many reports of neck pain relief. But customers must choose the right firmness option.

The pillow is made from a cotton cover and microfiber fill. This gives a down-like feel.

There is very low toxicity. Textiles are OEKO-TEX certified. The antimicrobial treatment is US EPA registered.

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow is made in the USA. Only high-quality materials are used in construction.

Customers usually get around 2 to 3 years of use. This is normal for high-quality microfiber pillows.

Most people do not report an odor. Any slight smell soon goes away.

Brooklinen have a 100% satisfaction guarantee. Customers can get a replacement pillow or a full refund. There is free return shipping.

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow review summary

Overall rating

4.3 out of 5
4.3 out of 5
Andy David
Rated & Review by Andy David
Comfort
 Good
Quality
 Good
Value
 Good
Side Sleepers
 Excellent
Neck & Back Pain
 Good
Cooling
 Good
Smell/Off-gassing
 Excellent
Company Reputation
 Excellent

Good

Good value, down-like pillow with a 365-night risk-free trial period.

Bad

Affordable, but not a budget brand. The pillow is dry clean only.

Buy or not

Buy for a supportive, microfiber pillow that feels like classic down. Customers wanting genuine down or a thinner loft should avoid.

Where To Buy The Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow?

The best place to buy the Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow is on the official website.  Click the button below to get the lowest price.

Lowest Pricefor Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow

About the author

Andy David
Andy David Mattress expert

Andy is the chief editor at Sleep Cupid. Andy researches and reviews leading mattress brands to help our readers get the right mattress and enjoy better rest.